Here’s an appropriate bracket for the day and the season:
Click on the bracket for the original, then on the bracket shown. Arrows will let you enlarge it from there to read the details. Spoiler: C.S. Lewis is a division champ, even though some of the others had at least 1000 years head start. 🙂
Cat Rotator's Quarterly 
I didn’t see any Lloyd Alexander.
His books might be a wee bit overly pagan for the theology students who voted on the bracket. Narnia and LoTR you don’t have to work as hard to see the Christian (or Christianity-compatible) themes.